why is fish not considered a meat. *when we eat them. But the language of the church is Latin, and what Catholics were not allowed to eat is 'carne' which is the flesh of creatures from the land or the sky. 6 years ago. 9 years ago. Historically, and currently in Orthodox tradition, fish is not allowed during fasts. 18 Answers. The Catholic Church has had a huge following for the past two millennia and people are too lazy to say "no meat except fish" 2. Are fish generally considered as meat...??? What your saying is that cold-blooded animals aren't meat, … Why is fish not considered a meat? Il y a 6 années. (which were made up by the Fish/Meat Conspirators no doubt). But many only consider warm-blooded animals as "meat". Fish isn't considered meat because English and Latin are slightly different languages.

Fish are pretty much their own thing, cold blooded creatures that breath water.

So H 6 years ago Report. Nonetheless, there are many people who will avoid all meat except for fish, or perhaps except for "white" meat which includes fish and poultry. After some research, the most likely explanation why fish isn't considered meat, is because the church law is written in Latin, which forbids eating 'carnis' (≙ the flesh of animals on land) on Fridays, so people just started eating fish. Well, that may not be a bad thing. Well known for being the reason behind the creation of the McDonald’s Fillet-o-Fish, and the fantastic tradition of buffalo wings, fish on Friday is one of the more well-known Catholic fasting traditions. This is seen in Catholicism, with the prohibition on meat during Lent. 1 15 13. 18 Answers. Favourite answer. Why do vegetarians and vegans don't consider fish as meat? A friend of mine recently had a discussion with several people who did not believe fish was meat. This study is interesting because it highlights a possible reason why red meat may not be good for you. Esoteric Order of Dagon. Anonyme. For hundreds of years Catholics were not allowed to eat meat on Friday.

If a person eats fish, they are not technically a vegetarian.. However, there are culinary and religious definitions that place fish in a different category. Some of their reasoning came from the fact that according to Catholic doctrine, they are allowed to eat fish on days where meat is prohibited. Someone changed the name to ‘Chilean Sea Bass’ and suddenly it’s on my list of the 25 best tasting fish in the world, and people have eaten so much of this fish that it’s now on the protected species list. Why Eating Fish Is Even More Dangerous Than You Thought Written by Environmental Working Group The Environmental Working Group is the nation’s most effective environmental health research and advocacy organization. 6 years ago. According to Saint Thomas Aquinas, the meat/fish divide boiled down to sex, simplicity, and farts. 15 Answers. Relevance. After over a half a year of studying, research, and prayer, I will be taking the first steps in joining the Catholic Church.

Lv 7. I blame religion for this – any logical person realizes fish are animals. Why do vegetarians and vegans don't consider fish as meat? While there may have been a time in history that poultry was not considered "meat," it was never forbidden with meat, as milk is. By some definitions, fish is considered meat, and by others, it isn’t. Favorite Answer. For Catholics, this is a category where the English language and religious doctrine do not mean the same thing. In culinary terms, fish and poultry are considered separate from meat, which is typically defined as the flesh of warm-blooded, land animals, such as cows, pigs, sheep and reptiles. Pertinence. the definition of meat is the flesh of an animal as food and last time i checked fish is flesh and is edible.. so you religious people out there, answer my question, explain to my why fish is not meat. Relevance. That is why they don't eat it. Why is fish not considered meat? 17) Salmon: To me this is the most overrated fish of all. Réponse préférée. Thereby making fish, but not beef or chicken o.k. This saying tells us that if we eat fish, which is also meat, we need to have red AND white wine. So favouring fish … Lv 7. Répondre Enregistrer. Many Catholics have told me fish is not meat. Well, they will stick around and confuse us. Fish is often overlooked as being meat because a lot of people assume that meat only comes from mammals and birds, … Fish is still meat but not what the latin word 'carnis' describes. Why? That is why they don't eat it.